Adorable Elf on the Shelf Cookies!

A few days ago, my daughter woke up to find our Elf on the Shelf, Peter, holding an Elf on the Shelf look-alike cookie!

There was much discussion about why he had brown eyes and who actually made the cookie. Was it Mrs. Claus or Peter himself? Was it full of magic?

We came to the conclusion that it WAS Mrs. Claus! If Peter had baked them, he would have made his elf cookie have blue eyes just like him.

Adorable Elf on the Shelf Cookies!

And of course it was magic!

I begged for one bite of the magical cookie from The North Pole.

She laughed. Then took a bite and laughed some more.

Adorable Elf on the Shelf Cookies!

After a few more bites and me obviously bugging her with more begging, she thought about it for a long time.

It was the ONLY cookie from The North Pole. Full of magic and probably made by Mrs. Claus herself. What’s a girl to do???

Adorable Elf on the Shelf Cookies!

She must REALLY love her mommy, because I ended up with an itsy bitsy teensy weensy corner of the cookie!

I guess a little magic is better than nothing.


Thanks to Elizabeth at Lizy B Bakes for making one more day of Elf magic in our home! Visit her blog to see more of the cute Elf on the Shelf Cookies.


Enjoy more Elf on the Shelf Ideas…

Plant “Magical North Pole” seeds and watch cookies grow!

Best idea! Elf on the Shelf Magic Seeds turn into cookies and a Free Printable Letter from Santa.


Photos from The North Pole’s Elf Appreciation Party!

Cute DIY printable idea for an Elf on the Shelf! Surprise your kids with mini photo booth party pictures from The North Pole.


Free Printable Santa Themed Gift Holder

Free Printable Santa Themed Paper Gift Card Holder for DIY Christmas Gifts by  Add a note or stickers from Santa or an Elf on the Shelf.


25 Fun and Easy Elf Ideas

25 Fun & Easy Elf On The Shelf Ideas. A Free Printable Posing Guide at


Get More Elf on the Shelf Ideas!

Over a Month of Elf on the Shelf Printables and Fun Ideas for kids at Christmas!



Share the fun!

Similar Posts


  1. So cute! What technique did you use for the eyes? Wet on wet icing, transfers, or did you pipe them on before flossing the face?

  2. Oh!!!! that’s so sweet! I ‘m so happy I could add a little magic to your daughter’s holiday. (and beyond thrilled that I could be Mrs. Claus for the day)

Comments are closed.